A serious potential challenge to our food supply is the mysterious mass illness and death of not only bees, but bats and hummingbirds as well. Without these pollinators, many of our fruits and vegetables would have to be pollinated by hand, as is already done in certain regions of China, where bees have completely disappeared.
An article on this topic in Scientific American (April 2009), made a comment that struck me. Theories about “colony collapse disorder” have focused on three areas: pesticides, viral infections, and habitat destruction. The comment: “We and other experts also suspected that the bees’ natural defenses might be undermined by poor nutrition. Honeybees — and wild pollinators, too — no longer have the same number or variety of flowers available because we humans have tried to “neaten” our environments… crops without weedy, flower-filled borders or hedgerows… To bees and other pollinators, green lawns look like deserts.”
So, the diets of pollinators lack important nutrients, and “beekeepers have attempted to manage these concerns by developing protein supplements.” Wild variety, replaced by monotonous diets, (only one species in the commercial crop they are pollinating) and protein supplements.
To me, this sounds eerily like the human epidemic of illnesses caused by a lack of food variety. Our modern diet is marked by a concentration on the macronutrients: carbs, protein and fat. At the same time, most of us miss out on the bewildering variety of micronutrition, such as antioxidants, minerals, and enzymes, naturally available in the wide assortment of edible produce and whole grains.
The name — or one of the names — of this severe dietary deficiency of micronutrition is “oxidative stress.” This severe form of stress results from an unfortunate side effect of metabolism: whenever fuel is burned for energy in the presence of oxygen, toxic byproducts are formed (analogous to smoke and soot.) This is why we need a wide variety of antioxidants, to neutralize these toxins.
I actually know nothing about bees — I would love it if my more knowledgeable readers would comment, here! So, of course, I went out on the world-wide web (isn’t it wonderful!) to see what I could find on the question of whether bees require antioxidants.
Most of the sources on bee nutrition that I found commented simply on sugar and protein. But this article pointed out that honey is a concentrated source of certain phenols, an important class of antioxidants for humans. Since bees make honey not for us, but to serve as their winter food source, perhaps they require those phenols?
Indeed, bees do suffer from oxidative stress. This research, though done on bees, focused more on the benefits of antioxidants for humans than for bees (at least as popularly reported. I didn’t find the text of the original paper).
I found just two other articles on oxidative stress in bees. Only one specifically found that oxidative stress in bees was found to be a strong factor in viral illnesses, just as it is in humans. The other article suggested that the oxidative stress of fast growth and intensive activity may cause premature aging and death in honeybees, also just as it does in humans.
So, to sum up, and make another logical leap — perhaps monotonous diets are destructive in almost all species. It seems our maniacal focus on a very few foods. most of which we process into a further nutrient-deficient state, is harmful to many more species beside our own.
If we grew vastly more varieties of produce, and many more varieties of flowers (and weeds) perhaps we’d be saving not just our own health, but also the birds and the bees.
Tweet This Post